New York City

The Edit  ·  Travel

New York, in two acts.

The trick to New York is to stop treating it as one city. Do it in two acts instead — a few nights uptown, where the city is old-world and residential, then move to the water downtown, where it's new again. Two hotels, two entirely different New Yorks, one trip.

Act I · Upper West Side

Start at The Wallace.

Base yourself first at The Wallace, tucked on a side street in the West 70s. It's the Upper West Side in hotel form — pre-war old-world charm, properly renovated rather than gutted, in a neighborhood where New Yorkers actually live. You're steps from Central Park and the Museum of Natural History, and the mornings are quiet in a way Midtown will never be.

One door away is a reason on its own: Citarella, the legendary Upper West Side gourmet market that began as a neighborhood fish shop in 1912. Walk the seafood counter even if you're not buying — it's some of the freshest fish on the island, iced and laid out like a market in Tokyo. This is how the neighborhood eats, and it tells you everything about why people never leave it.

Manhattan

The Midtown Evening

MoMA, crystal, and the hardest table in New York.

Here's a well-kept secret of Midtown geography: three of the best things on this itinerary sit within two blocks of each other on 53rd and 55th. Do them as one evening.

Spend the late afternoon at MoMA — go in with a short list (the fifth-floor collection alone justifies the ticket) rather than trying to see everything. Then cross 53rd Street, literally, to the Baccarat Hotel, where the second-floor Grand Salon is one of the most beautiful bars in the city — chandeliers and glowing red-box vitrines from the 260-year-old French crystal house, and every drink served in Baccarat crystal. Go at the blue hour, order something stirred, and hold it up to the light.

Then walk two blocks north to dinner at The Polo Bar, Ralph Lauren's clubby, equestrian-paneled dining room under one of the great ceilings in New York. An honest note: the food is good, not transcendent — you're there for the room, which is transporting, and for the sport of having gotten in at all. That part takes strategy:

How to actually book The Polo Bar
  1. Call — there is no online booking. Reservations are taken by phone only: 212-207-8562.
  2. Exactly 30 days out, at 10:00 a.m. Eastern. Tables release on the matching calendar date — to dine on the 30th, call at 10 a.m. on the 30th of the month before.
  3. Expect to hold. Thirty to ninety minutes on hold is normal. Put the phone on speaker and go about your morning; the table is worth it.
  4. Take the 5 or the 10. Openings skew to 5 p.m. or 10 p.m. Take one — the room is the show at any hour.
  5. Struck out? Call back around 4 p.m. on the day you want to dine for cancellations, or route through a concierge — Amex Platinum's dining desk has been known to work minor miracles here.

Dress the part — jackets aren't required, but this is Ralph Lauren's living room, and the staff notices.

Uptown is where New York keeps its past. Downtown, by the water, is where it's building what comes next.

Downtown and the East River

Act II · Downtown

Move to the water.

For the second act, change hotels — it feels extravagant and it completely remakes the trip. Check in at The Wall Street Hotel, a polished boutique property in the old financial district, where the streets are cobbled, narrow, and nearly silent at night once the traders go home.

The move that makes this act sing: skip the subway and commute by water. From Pier 11 — a couple of minutes' walk from the hotel — the river taxi crosses the East River to Dumbo in a few minutes flat, with the Brooklyn Bridge overhead and the best skyline view in the city for the price of a sandwich. Get off and walk the cobblestones to Butler for coffee — a bright, Australian-style café that does flat whites and pastries properly. Coffee in hand, bridge above you, Manhattan across the water: it's the cheapest world-class morning New York offers.

The West Village Night

A corner table at B'artusi.

Save one evening for the West Village and take a corner seat at B'artusi, at Hudson and West 10th — the all-day wine bar from the team behind L'Artusi, one of the city's most beloved Italian rooms. Vintage mirrors, a marble bar, Italian small plates built for sharing, and a serious wine list without any ceremony. It's walk-in friendly, which by current New York standards makes it practically a public service — go early, order the tartare and whatever pasta they suggest, and let the evening unspool.

Two hotels, one river crossing, and the hardest reservation in Manhattan — that's New York done properly. Planning a trip, or comparing city life to the desert kind? Marta is always happy to trade notes.

The Edit · Marta Walsh
← Back to The Edit